Spears' diagnosis is her OWN business | Behavioral Healthcare Executive Skip to content Skip to navigation

Spears' diagnosis is her OWN business

April 4, 2008
by Doug Edwards
| Reprints

Today I received details about a book that investigates the death of Marilyn Monroe, and the e-mail mentions that the author, a clinical psychologist, "diagnosed Britney Spears with a very similar if not the same illness as Marilyn." I am dismayed that a few irresponsible behavioral healthcare professionals continue to capitalize on celebrities' psychiatric problems (and violate their professional associations' standards in the process). No matter how sincere their efforts may be, the entertainment outlets sensationalize these "diagnoses," which further promotes stigma. As most reputable clinicians know, you shouldn't diagnose someone based on media reports! Of course, looking at the possible behavioral health disorders of "celebrities" can provide insights into the decisions made by important people (Abraham Lincoln's history of depression comes to mind). Speculating on Monroe's problems doesn't irk me. But while people areobviously and
actively struggling with behavioral health problems, these few professionals would be wise to keep their opinions to themselves and focus on the many needs of their current patients. Below is the e-mail.




I agree with the title of this blog: Spears' diagnosis is her OWN business! Just as everyone elses diagnosis is their own business. Unless Britney signed a release to the public, I do not understand how this can be broadcast. Although the media has their ways... it still doesn't make it right.

It's a deadly combination when the media has apparently changed its mission from reporting the news to becoming the news at the same time that the American public embraces sensationalism as the new truth. The masses can't get enough of Britney and can't get far enough away from science.


Doug Edwards

Vice President and Managing Director

Doug Edwards


Doug Edwards is Vice President and Managing Director of Vendome Healthcare Media’s Mental Health...

The opinions expressed by Behavioral Healthcare Executive bloggers and those providing comments are theirs alone and are not meant to reflect the opinions of the publication.